Which type of feedback is least beneficial for improving writing?

Which type of feedback is least beneficial for improving writing?

• A. Constructive criticism
• B. Positive affirmations
• C. Specific suggestions on structure
• D. General suggestions about style

Answer: (B)

Positive affirmations can boost a writer's confidence and morale, but they do not provide specific guidance on areas that need improvement or detail on how to enhance their writing. While it’s important to acknowledge a writer's strengths, the absence of constructive feedback means that the writer may not gain insight into the areas where they could do better. Feedback that lacks specificity does not engage with the nuances of their work, making it less beneficial for improving writing skills. In contrast, constructive criticism and specific suggestions about structure give clear directions for what can be improved and how to approach revisions. General suggestions about style might help a writer think about their work in a broader sense, but without specifics, they may find it challenging to implement those suggestions effectively.

Positive affirmations can boost a writer's confidence and morale, but they do not provide specific guidance on areas that need improvement or detail on how to enhance their writing. While it’s important to acknowledge a writer's strengths, the absence of constructive feedback means that the writer may not gain insight into the areas where they could do better. Feedback that lacks specificity does not engage with the nuances of their work, making it less beneficial for improving writing skills.

In contrast, constructive criticism and specific suggestions about structure give clear directions for what can be improved and how to approach revisions. General suggestions about style might help a writer think about their work in a broader sense, but without specifics, they may find it challenging to implement those suggestions effectively.